Side by sip · wine comparison

Wine VS

Line up two to four wines the way you'd say them. The guide covers 127 appellations and styles, and spelling doesn't need to be perfect.

Try
On the bench1Barossa Shiraz2Hermitage

Barossa Shiraz vs Hermitage

Barossa Shiraz and Hermitage side by side: structure on the WSET scale, grapes, aromas, drinking window, typical UK price and what to eat with each.

1

Barossa Shiraz

South Australia · Barossa Valley, Australia
redOpaque purple

Big, ripe and lush Shiraz with sweet dark fruit and soft acidity.

2

Hermitage

Northern Rhône, France
redOpaque purple

The most powerful Syrah of France; dense and long-lived.

Structure

On the palate

The shape of each wine, then each measure on the WSET scale.

SweetnessBodyTanninAcidityAlcoholOak
LowMed–MediumMed+High
Sweetnessdry → luscious
1
2
Body
1
2
Tannin
1
2
Acidity
1
2
Alcohol
1
2
Oak
1
2
What stands out

What you'll notice

  • Acidity

    Hermitage has noticeably fresher acidity than Barossa Shiraz.

  • Grapes

    Barossa Shiraz: Shiraz, often from very old ungrafted vines
    Hermitage: Syrah (up to 15% white Marsanne/Roussanne allowed)

Ageing & price

When to drink, what to pay

Drinking window years from vintage

1 · Barossa Shiraz
5–20 yrs
2 · Hermitage
15–40 yrs
051020304050

Typical price UK retail, log scale

1 · Barossa Shiraz
£15–100
2 · Hermitage
£50–250
£5£10£20£50£100£200£500
In the glass

Aromas & flavours

Black fruitHerbal & greenEarth & mineralSpice, oak & savoury
1Barossa Shiraz
blackberry jamchocolateliquoriceeucalyptusblack pepper
2Hermitage
blackberryblack peppersmoketarleather
The detail

Place, grapes & food

Barossa ShirazHermitage
GrapesShiraz, often from very old ungrafted vinesSyrah (up to 15% white Marsanne/Roussanne allowed)
ClimateWarm, dry MediterraneanContinental, one south-facing granite hill
SoilRed-brown earth, sand and clayGranite with loess and alluvium
ClassificationGIAOC
Drinking window5–20 years15–40 years
Typical price£15–£100£50–£250
FoodBarbecue, smoked brisket, lamb shoulderBeef, game, aged cheeses
Producers to knowTorbreck, Rockford, PenfoldsJean-Louis Chave, Paul Jaboulet Aîné (La Chapelle), M. Chapoutier