Side by sip · wine comparison

Wine VS

Line up two to four wines the way you'd say them. The guide covers 127 appellations and styles, and spelling doesn't need to be perfect.

Try
On the bench1Napa Valley Cabernet2Coonawarra Cabernet

Napa Valley Cabernet vs Coonawarra Cabernet

Napa Valley Cabernet and Coonawarra Cabernet side by side: structure on the WSET scale, grapes, aromas, drinking window, typical UK price and what to eat with each.

1

Napa Valley Cabernet

California · Napa Valley, USA
redDeep purple

Ripe, polished and generous: riper fruit and more new oak than Bordeaux.

2

Coonawarra Cabernet

South Australia · Limestone Coast, Australia
redDeep ruby

Minty, structured Australian Cabernet.

Structure

On the palate

The shape of each wine, then each measure on the WSET scale.

SweetnessBodyTanninAcidityAlcoholOak
LowMed–MediumMed+High
Sweetnessdry → luscious
1
2
Body
1
2
Tannin
1
2
Acidity
1
2
Alcohol
1
2
Oak
1
2
What stands out

What you'll notice

  • Oak

    Napa Valley Cabernet has noticeably more oak influence than Coonawarra Cabernet.

  • Grapes

    Napa Valley Cabernet: Cabernet Sauvignon, often with some Merlot
    Coonawarra Cabernet: Cabernet Sauvignon

Ageing & price

When to drink, what to pay

Drinking window years from vintage

1 · Napa Valley Cabernet
8–25 yrs
2 · Coonawarra Cabernet
8–20 yrs
051020304050

Typical price UK retail, log scale

1 · Napa Valley Cabernet
£30–300
2 · Coonawarra Cabernet
£15–60
£5£10£20£50£100£200£500
In the glass

Aromas & flavours

Black fruitHerbal & greenSpice, oak & savoury
1Napa Valley Cabernet
blackcurrantblack cherryvanillamochamint
2Coonawarra Cabernet
blackcurrantminteucalyptuscedar
The detail

Place, grapes & food

Napa Valley CabernetCoonawarra Cabernet
GrapesCabernet Sauvignon, often with some MerlotCabernet Sauvignon
ClimateWarm Mediterranean with cooling fogCool maritime
SoilVolcanic and alluvial benchlandTerra rossa over limestone
ClassificationAVA, with sub-AVAs such as Oakville and RutherfordGI
Drinking window8–25 years8–20 years
Typical price£30–£300£15–£60
FoodRibeye, burgers, aged cheddarLamb
Producers to knowStag's Leap Wine Cellars, Robert Mondavi, Heitz CellarWynns, Balnaves, Penley Estate