Side by sip · wine comparison

Wine VS

Line up two to four wines the way you'd say them. The guide covers 127 appellations and styles, and spelling doesn't need to be perfect.

Try
On the bench1Margaux2Saint-Émilion3Pomerol

Margaux vs Saint-Émilion vs Pomerol

Margaux, Saint-Émilion and Pomerol side by side: structure on the WSET scale, grapes, aromas, drinking window, typical UK price and what to eat with each.

1

Margaux

Bordeaux · Left Bank, Haut-Médoc, France
redDeep ruby

The perfumed, silky side of the Left Bank: floral and fine-grained rather than muscular.

2

Saint-Émilion

Bordeaux · Right Bank, Libournais, France
redDeep ruby

Rounder and plummier than the Left Bank, with Cabernet Franc's herbal lift and limestone freshness.

3

Pomerol

Bordeaux · Right Bank, Libournais, France
redDeep purple-ruby

Opulent and velvety: the plushest, most fleshy expression of Merlot in Bordeaux.

Structure

On the palate

The shape of each wine, then each measure on the WSET scale.

SweetnessBodyTanninAcidityAlcoholOak
LowMed–MediumMed+High
Sweetnessdry → luscious
1
2
3
Body
1
2
3
Tannin
1
2
3
Acidity
1
2
3
Alcohol
1
2
3
Oak
1
2
3
What stands out

What you'll notice

  • Structure

    These are close in structure; the differences are mostly in grape, aroma and place.

  • Grapes

    Margaux: Cabernet Sauvignon-led (about 60%), Merlot, a little Cabernet Franc and Petit Verdot
    Saint-Émilion: Merlot-led (about 60–70%) with Cabernet Franc, some Cabernet Sauvignon
    Pomerol: Merlot-dominant (often 70–100%), with Cabernet Franc

Ageing & price

When to drink, what to pay

Drinking window years from vintage

1 · Margaux
10–30 yrs
2 · Saint-Émilion
8–25 yrs
3 · Pomerol
8–30 yrs
051020304050

Typical price UK retail, log scale

1 · Margaux
£30–150+
2 · Saint-Émilion
£20–150+
3 · Pomerol
£40–300+
£5£10£20£50£100£200£500
In the glass

Aromas & flavours

Red fruitBlack fruitFloralHerbal & greenEarth & mineralSpice, oak & savoury
1Margaux
violetblackcurrantcedargraphiterose petal
2Saint-Émilion
plumred cherryfresh herbstobaccomocha
3Pomerol
black cherryplumtrufflechocolateviolet
The detail

Place, grapes & food

MargauxSaint-ÉmilionPomerol
GrapesCabernet Sauvignon-led (about 60%), Merlot, a little Cabernet Franc and Petit VerdotMerlot-led (about 60–70%) with Cabernet Franc, some Cabernet SauvignonMerlot-dominant (often 70–100%), with Cabernet Franc
ClimateMaritime; the most southerly of the four great Médoc communesMaritime with more continental influence than the MédocMaritime with continental influence
SoilThin, very free-draining gravel over limestone and clayLimestone plateau, clay-limestone slopes, sand and gravel belowClay and gravel; iron-rich blue clay at the heart of the plateau
Classification1855 Classification: 21 classed growths, more than any other communeSaint-Émilion Classification, revised roughly every ten years; Premier Grand Cru Classé A at the topNo official classification; tiny family estates
Drinking window10–30 years8–25 years8–30 years
Typical price£30–£150 (first growth far more)£20–£150 (top estates far more)£40–£300 (Pétrus and Le Pin in the thousands)
FoodRack of lamb, roast beef, mushroom dishesDuck breast, lamb, roast vegetablesBeef fillet, truffle dishes, roast game birds
Producers to knowChâteau Margaux, Château Palmer, Château Rauzan-SéglaChâteau Figeac, Château Pavie, Château CanonPétrus, Vieux Château Certan, Château L'Évangile